NFR Project: 'The Ox-Bow Incident' (1943)

 

NFR Project: “The Ox-Bow Incident”

Dir: William A. Wellman

Scr: Lamar Trotti

Pho: Arthur C. Miller

Ed: Allen McNeil

Premiere: May 21, 1943

75 min.

Westerns, for the first 40 or so years of their existence, were shoot-‘em-ups, adventures primarily for kids to watch. They featured a hero, a villain, a girl in danger. They consisted of chases on horseback, gunplay, fistfights. Good always triumphed in the end.

Then along came The Ox-Bow Incident, the first Western that could be dubbed adult, or psychological, or noir. It’s adapted from the 1940 novel by Walter Van Tilburg Clark. Clark was noted for his ability to take the Western genre and infuse it with adult sensibilities, psychological complexities, and moral ambiguities. This film is faithful to the novel, dealing with issues of justice and morality while painting the West as not an escapist destination, but as a hard, cruel landscape populated by flawed characters.

In the movie, two saddle pals (Henry Fonda, Harry Morgan) ride into a Nevada town in 1885. They go to the local saloon and proceed to get drunk. Suddenly, a man rides in to town and announces that a local rancher has been murdered and his cattle stolen. The men of the town decide to form a posse and go after the perpetrators, despite the warnings of the kindly Mr. Davies (Harry Davenport). They are led by a self-righteous Army vet, Major Tetley (Frank Conroy).

The posse rides out, and is soon enveloped in darkness. Climbing up into the mountains, the lynch mob encounters three men camped out – a rancher (Dana Andrews), a Mexican (Anthony Quinn), and a befuddled old man (the reliable Francis Ford, brother of John). Based on circumstantial evidence, the posse decides that the three are guilty and are determined to string them up. Only seven men vote against the lynching; a sizable majority wants to kill the men.

Despite the men’s pleas that they are innocent, the hangings proceed. Almost immediately after, the sheriff rides up and announces that not only wasn’t the rancher killed, but that the real criminals were captured. Everyone is in shock, and they ride quietly back to town, where they all proceed to drink. Fonda reads the eloquent last letter of Andrews to his wife, and the two pals determine to seek her out and give her the news. They ride away down the dusty, empty street of the town.

Director William Wellman shoots most of the movie in near darkness. Light and shadow play across the faces of the characters as they debate, agonize, and anticipate the hangings. The mood of the film is grim and subdued; the posse’s bloodlust and disregard for the law is underlined. This gritty and uncompromising take on the Western confounded studio executives, but earned the film a Best Picture Oscar nomination. 

Many of Hollywood’s best character actors are on hand to fill out the ensemble, including the sinister Marc Lawrence as Farnley, the instigator, Jane Darwell as rancher “Ma” Grier, and Leigh Whipper as Sparks, an itinerant preacher. (Whipper was the first African-American to join Actors’ Equity; he plays a nuanced character not burdened by the stereotyped behavior that dogged Black actors at the time.)

The film is a tragedy, one that clearly delineates the causes of injustice and condemns “frontier justice” and the herd instinct that drives men to kill each other on nothing more than vague suspicions. This noir Western would inspire many more in the decades to come. The Western had finally grown up.

The NFR is one writer’s attempt to review all the films listed in the National Film Registry in chronological order. Next time: Shadow of a Doubt.