NFR Project: ‘Show Boat’
Dir: James Whale
Scr: Oscar Hammerstein II
Pho: John J. Mescall
Ed: Bernard W. Burton, Ted Kent
Premiere: May 17, 1936
113 min.
The director James Whale’s favorite film of his was quite
unlike his usual output. Best known as a horror director, Whale’s assured foray
into an epic musical theater production is a great adaptation of a stage
classic to film.
Show Boat started a revolution in musical
theater. Until it premiered, musicals were scattershot affairs – loose
collections of sketches and songs, or light-hearted fluff and farce, or
operettas set in imaginary European kingdoms. With the creation of Show
Boat, a musical with three-dimensional characters and a serious plot, the
musical grew up.
It didn’t hurt that some of America’s most enduring ballads
are studded throughout the work. “Bill,” “Can’t Help Lovin’ That Man of Mine,”
“Make Believe,” “You Are Love,” and of course the iconic “Ol’ Man River – all
are classics that continue to be performed today by jazz and cabaret artists.
The songs all serve to advance the plot, and stand on their own as well, as all
catchy tunes should.
The musical was adapted from a 1926 novel by the
best-selling author Edna Ferber. It’s an epic story that plays out between 1887
and 1927, from the banks of the Mississippi to the theaters of New York City,
encompassing the evolution of American music from old-time sentimental ballads
through bluesy torch songs and on to jazzy standards. Kern had plenty of
practice as a songsmith – he’d already been in the business for 20 years, and
had cranked out 16 musicals between 1915 and 1920. Hammerstein was similarly
experienced.
The story involves the steamboat Cotton Blossom,
which serves as a floating, traveling theater along the banks of the
Mississippi River. Its owners, Cap’n Andy and Parthy, have a daughter,
Magnolia. When it revealed that the show’s leading lady, Julie, is of mixed
race, she is forced to leave the show boat. Her role is taken over by Magnolia,
who acts opposite the charming gambler Gaylord Ravenal.
Magnolia and Gaylord end up together and have a daughter,
but, impoverished and ashamed, Gaylord leaves the two of them. Magnolia goes on
to be a successful singer in a club thanks to the selfless sacrifice of Julie.
Twenty years later, Magnolia and Gaylord are reunited at their daughter’s
Broadway debut.
The musical was the first to deal with racism, and has been
accused of a kind of racism itself. While the “n-word” is bandied about freely
in the original script, later times have caused alternations to accommodate
better sensibilities. It deals frankly with the scourges of the time: the
segregation of black and white populations, the inability of a mixed-race
person to be thought of as little better than an animal. No one had tried to
seriously engage these thorny issues on stage before. Merely the act of having
black and white performers on stage together was seen as the breaking of a
taboo.
Whale recruited many of the show’s original performers to
recreate their roles for the film. In particular, Charles Winninger’s
definitive rendition of Cap’n Andy, Magnolia’s happy-go-lucky father is a treat.
Though she is 20 years too old for the part, Irene Dunne does a meritable job
as Magnolia, tenor Allan Jones proves himself to be a bit of an actor as
Gaaylord Ravenal.
Of particular merit are the performances of Helen Morgan and
Paul Robeson. Morgan, a well-known torch singer, was the original Julie, and
her renditions of “Bill” and “Can’t Help . . .” are iconic – musically superior
and heart-rending. And, of course, Robeson is purely and magnetically Robeson
in the role he originated in the London production, a role no one else could
play to satisfaction.
This became his signature song, one he would reprise with
more hopeful lyrics throughout his career. It’s the best remembered song from a
history-making production.
America’s systemic cultural racism of the time is on display
here. The Black people in the film are depicted as simple-minded and none too
ambitious; Magnolia does a blackface number that is interesting today only for
its documentary value.
Yet Whale wrestles the cold, hard facts of segregation and
racism, topics generally never covered in Hollywood film of the time. Show
Boat represents the one-step-forward, two-steps-back struggle of Black
people to be taken seriously as people.
The NFR is one
writer’s attempt to review all the films listed in the National Film Registry
in chronological order. Next time: Swing Time.