NFR Project: “A Star is Born”
Dir: George Cukor
Scr: Moss Hart
Pho: Sam Leavitt
Ed: Folmar Blangsted
Premiere: Sept. 12, 1954
182/154/178 min.
This film is all about the wonder that is Judy Garland.
The childhood star of The Wizard of Oz was afflicted with
illness and substance abuse problems as her career progressed at MGM. She was
universally popular, but she was manipulated and abused by those in charge of
her career. Gradually, she became incapable of performing. In 1950, her
contract with MGM was suspended.
After some rehab and a return to live performance, she and her then-husband
and -manager Sid Luft came up with the idea to remake William Wellman’s 1937 melodrama
A Star Is Born as a vehicle for her comeback.
This time, the plot of the movie was augmented with a number of musical
performances by Garland. This hybrid of musical theater and melodrama proved to
be a winner.
Garland plays Esther Blodgett, a struggling performer in L.A. trying to
get noticed. She meets Norman Maine (James Mason), a matinee idol with a severe
drinking problem. He falls for her and helps her break into the big time. She
becomes a big star, with a new name, Vicki Lester – but at the same time,
Norman’s career goes to hell in a handbasket. After an attempt at rehab, he
finally gives up and kills himself, walking into the ocean. Vicky/Esther
appears at a benefit immediately after, proudly identifying herself s “Mrs.
Norman Maine.”
Garland suffers exquisitely throughout the film. She loves Norman, but
his self-destructive behavior drives her to distraction. Judy does the best
acting of her career in the offstage portions of the film, and dazzles during
the musical sequences. (Her big number, the “Born In a Trunk” sequence, was
filmed after Cukor left the production, and was inserted to beef up her screen
time.)
The initial cut of the film was 182 minutes, but the studio cut it down
by a half-hour in order to accommodate more showings in theaters. Decades
later, much of the footage was restored, giving us a much better sense of story
than the original commercial release.
Cukor’s ability to capture the feelings of women onscreen was
unmatched, and his visual sense is impeccable. Working in Technicolor and CinemaScope
for the first time, he makes it look easy. This is still the definitive version
of this classic show-biz story.
The NFR Project is one writer’s attempt to
review all the films listed in the National Film Registry in chronological
order. Next time: A Time
Out of War.