NFR Project: “Twelve O’Clock High”
Dir: Henry King
Scr: Henry King, Sy Bartlett, Beirne Lay Jr.
Pho: Leon Shamroy
Ed: Barbara McLean
Premiere: Dec. 21, 1949
132 min.
American war movies
made during World War II were pure propaganda – gung-ho adventure stories in
which the bad guys, the Nazis and the “Japs,” always lost. There was no shading,
no questioning of the effort. It took a few years for more nuanced examinations
of the conflict to appear on film.
One of the best is Twelve
O’Clock High. It’s the fact-based story of an American bomber group in England
in 1942. At that time, they were the only part of the American fighting forces to
do battle with Nazi Germany. In order to blunt the German war effort, they
engaged in daylight bombing of enemy targets. The difficulty and danger of
these sorties were magnified by the fact that Allied fighter planes at the time
did not have the range that would allow them to protect the bombers. B-17s flew
into enemy airspace guarded only by their own guns.
The pressure was
intense, as the higher-ups called for “maximum effort” – an unrelenting
schedule of bombing raids, day after day, despite losses and despite the
fatigue of its crews. Twelve O’Clock High takes on the story of the
imaginary 918th Bomber Group. Its efficiency is questioned, and complaints
center on the attitude of its commander, Col. Davenport (Gary Merrill). Major Gen.
Pritchard (Millard Mitchell) decides to replace him with Brigadier Gen. Savage
(Gregory Peck), a by-the-book man who takes the tough-love approach with his
fliers.
He is assisted by
the capable and thoughtful Group Adjutant, Major Stovall (Dean Jagger) and the
group doctor, Major Kaiser (Paul Stewart). Savage reads the riot act to his
men, demoting some and disciplining others. All the pilots request transfers.
Savage delays their
requests while he struggles to earn their confidence. He finds himself moved by
the efforts and attitudes of his airmen, and begins to unbend. The transfer
requests are withdrawn.
The action takes
place in and around the base; the film could be a stage play save for a long
combat sequence late in the film, culled entirely from documentary footage.
Gradually, he begins
to identify with his men. He becomes more and more concerned with their
survival, as the missions become longer and more devastating to the attackers.
Finally, Savage finds himself incapable of entering his airplane for a mission.
Catatonic, he is returned to base while his men fly off without him. It’s only
when they return safely that he snaps out of it and goes to sleep.
All this is
bracketed by the post-war visit of Stovall to the old field – this is a memory
play, his memory. We never learn what happened to Savage.
The movie is a
textbook study of the management of men – in this case, men in battle. Despite
the formalities and conventions of military life, the human factor bleeds
through and engulfs even the hardest-hearted general. Peck is solid as Savage,
and Jagger delivers a Best Supporting Actor Oscar-winning performance as Stovall.
Gary Merrill and Millard Mitchell, usually not seen in centra roles, do a great
job in their performances. Hugh Marlow, in particular, makes am memorable
impression as disgraced pilot Gately.
Vulnerable men try
to do the impossible, and they largely succeed. But at what cost?
The NFR is one writer’s attempt to review all
the films listed in the National Film Registry in chronological order. Next time: White Heat.