Sunrise: A Song of
Two Humans
Dir: F.W. Murnau
Scr: Carl Mayer
Pho: Charles Rosher, Karl
Struss
Ed: Harold Schuster
Premiere: September
23, 1927
95 min.
This would not be
the last time that critics acclaimed a film that the public ignored. Sunrise:
A Song of Two Humans is self-consciously arty – it won the only Oscar for Unique
and Artistic Picture at the very first Oscars ceremony in 1929. It won Best
Cinematography for Charles Rosher and Karl Struss. The lead actress Janet Gaynor
won the first Best Actress award for this (and for her work in Street Angel [1928]).
However, it did not
earn back its rather extravagant budget. It was the first American project of
the famed German director F.W. Murnau, who up to this time had created classics
such as Nosferatu: A Symphony of Horror (1922), The Last Laugh (1924),
and Faust (1926) in his native country. He was brought to Hollywood with
a reputation that gave him great leeway in the production of the film.
Murnau made the most
of his opportunity. Often cited as one of the greatest films ever made, it sweeps
the viewer into a penetratingly compelling story that needs no words to make
itself understood.
It tells of a farmer
(George O’Brien) and his wife (Gaynor). A “city woman” (Margaret Livingston) seduces
him. We begin with the principals in mid-misery, one from guilt and the other from
sorrow. The city woman urges the farmer to kill his wife, sell his farm, and
come to the city with her.
Double exposures
reveal the farmer’s thoughts, contrasting with his anguished features. The
filmmakers track down complex paths through the studio-created marshes, embodying
the meandering, wavering walk of the guilty husband. The two embark on an
ominous journey via boat to the city. The farmer stands over his wife, ready to
kill, then abruptly relents.
What happens next is
the entire play of two personalities, running through the emotions of despair,
fear, shame, forgiveness, and reconciliation, all in the context of a visit to
a vivid, Expressionistic cityscape. Murnau moves the story on with economy and
precision, mirroring camera setups, gestures, postures, using all the resources
of the pictorial field and the actors’ skill to convey a true love story.
Murnau slows down
the pace and lets the camera linger n the face of his actors. He allows them to
move through multiple states of thought; patiently, he records their reactions
and realizations. The story is a simple melodrama, but Murnau and his collaborators
find the truth and beauty in the tale and bring it to life.
Not only are the
visuals beautiful, moody, and expressive, but the film is graced with the
addition of sound, of a kind. While not a talking picture, a soundtrack of
music and effects was married to the print and played in the early sound-film
houses. Hugo Riesenfeld’s score carefully reinforces the images and feelings
onscreen.
The picture’s
unexpectedly melodramatic ending could easily be seen as far-fetched (the farmer
considered drowning his wife, and then loses her in a storm on the water on
their way home), but the film is so involving that it allows the suspension of
disbelief to continue.
Sunrise is a revelation of feeling couched in a familiar
story of universal appeal. It does what silent film did best – it transcends
cultural barriers, making itself intelligible to everyone.
The NFR is one
writer’s attempt to review all the films listed in the National Film Registry
in chronological order. Next time: Wings.