NFR Project: 'Mr. Smith Goes to Washington' (1939)

 

NFR Project: ‘Mr. Smith Goes to Washington’

Dir: Frank Capra

Scr: Sidney Buchman, Myles Connolly

Pho: Joseph Walker

Ed: Gene Havlick, Al Clark

Premiere: Oct. 17, 1939

130 min.

The director Frank Capra (1897-1991) is frequently disparaged as a terminal optimist. He’s a flag-waver, a vehement believer in truth, justice, and the American way. However, there’s a dark side to his popular and awarded “message” pictures, one that isn’t dispelled by their inevitable happy endings.

Capra got his start at the bottom, working all kinds of jobs and finally finding himself, through luck and bluff, contributing as a gag writer to Hal Roach’s silent Our Gang comedy shorts. Then he moved up to directing the comedian Harry Langdon in a series of successful silent films. Finally, he began to choose and create his own projects.

He struck paydirt with It Happened One Night, which won several Oscars, including Best Director for Capra. Two more of his films, Mr. Deeds Goes to Town and You Can’t Take It With You, earned him Oscars as well. He was flying in industry esteem, then, when he picked his next project Mr. Smith Goes to Washington.

No film executives wanted to film this picture, feeling that its discussion of political corruption would be a black eye for America, at home and abroad. A determined Capra pushed the project through.

It’s the story of naïve young Jefferson Smith (Jimmy Stewart in a career-defining role), a publisher and scoutmaster who’s chosen to fill a Senate seat vacated by death. Little does he know that the multimedia tycoon James Taylor (Edward Arnold, marvelously villainous) really runs things in his home state, with the help of “the Silver Knight, ” Senator Paine (Claude Rains), Smith’s late father’s friend, who’s in conspiracy with him. Together they plan to pass a bill that establishes a dam built on property they’ve bought up on the sly. Their immediate goal is to keep Smith busy and distracted, so he doesn’t ask any questions about the bill.

Smith is abused by the press as a stooge, a know-nothing. His cynical, wisecracking assistant Saunders (Jean Arthur) takes pity on him, and attempts to tell how politics really work in Washington. Smith comes up with a bill of his own – the creation of national boys’ camp, unfortunately situated right where Taylor and Paine want to set up their dam. Smith discovers the conspiracy, and attempts to denounce it, but he is interrupted by Paine, who accuses him of using his bill to line his own pockets.

Soon Smith is up on charges of graft, and Taylor and his media outlets suppress his side of the story and demonize him, even going far as to forge documents insinuating Smith’s guilt. As a last-ditch effort, Smith begins a filibuster on the Senate floor, with the bemused support of the president of the Senate (Harry Carey). Taloy and his machine keep blackening Smith’s name, even going to far as to firehouse marchers and injure children distributing newspapers containing the truth.

An exhausted Smith is confronted with stacks of telegrams and letters against, finally collapses. Suddenly, Paine dashes from the room and attempts to kill himself, then runs back onto the Senate floor and confesses everything. Smith is saved.

The movie follows the pattern of many Capra films. The idealistic hero is brought down to earth by the realities of an uncaring world. He is knocked down, but not out, when others, the common people, rally around him and bring about his redemption. These finishes are crowd-pleasers, but they strain to express their ecstatic vaunting of common sense and good will. Capra believes in the power of the people – but his unrealistic endings make his sentiments appear are merely wishful thinking.

Stewart was perfect for the role, and he is aided and abetted by some of Hollywood’s best character actors – Capra’s “regulars” such as Thomas Mitchell, Eugene Pallette, Beulah Bondi, Guy Kibbee, and H.B. Warner. They are regulars in Capra’s films over the years, and they too are well-matched with their parts. The direction is unobtrusive and low-key, save for the patriotic montages concocted by the master editor Slavko Vorkapich.

When the film was released, it caused a lot of controversy. Some thought the film denigrated democracy. In truth, Capra’s revelation of how power brokers have their way with the American political process is deeply subversive, and it’s not quite cancelled out by the film’s abrupt happy ending. Taylors and Paines still abound, and the film is particularly apt for viewing in our present time of governmental corruption and scandal.

The NFR is one writer’s attempt to review all the films listed in the National Film Registry in chronological order. Next time: Ninotchka.